Evidence from a feasibility study guides climate-resilient sexual and reproductive health and rights interventions in India’s Sundarbans
A feasibility study shows how climate change, social norms, and institutional barriers combine to limit access to sexual and reproductive health services in the Indian Sundarbans.
The findings provide an evidence base for climate-resilient SRHR programming, stronger public services, and greater participation by adolescent girls and women in local decision-making.
Climate change is increasingly recognised as a public health and gender equality challenge. In highly exposed regions such as the Sundarbans, recurrent cyclones, flooding, salinity, displacement, and livelihood pressure affect more than physical infrastructure. They also influence adolescent health, child marriage, early pregnancy, mobility, and access to sexual and reproductive health and rights services.
To support evidence-based project design, German Doctors e. V. and the Dearah Association for Social and Humanitarian Action commissioned movimentar GmbH to conduct a feasibility study for the proposed project “Strengthening Sexual and Reproductive Health and Rights of Girls and Women in the Sundarbans, India.”
The study examined five blocks in North 24 Parganas, West Bengal: Minakhan, Basirhat II, Sandeshkhali I, Hasnabad, and Hingalganj. It combined primary research with an assessment of the public health system, local institutional capacities, social norms, protection risks, and the relationship between climate vulnerability and access to SRHR services.
Why the context matters
The Sundarbans is a densely populated deltaic region exposed to cyclones, tidal flooding, riverbank erosion, saline water intrusion, and shortages of safe drinking water. These hazards repeatedly disrupt transport, health services, schools, livelihoods, and community support systems.
Girls and women experience these pressures through existing gender inequalities. Families often control adolescent mobility and health decisions. Social stigma discourages confidential care-seeking. Economic and environmental stress can increase exposure to early marriage, early pregnancy, unsafe migration, and trafficking.
Government programmes and adolescent-friendly health services exist. However, the study found a persistent gap between the formal availability of services and their effective use. Many potential users do not know which services exist, how to reach them, what procedures they must follow, or whether they will receive confidential and respectful care.
The feasibility study approach
The study applied a mixed-methods design aligned with BMZ and OECD/DAC feasibility criteria. It assessed relevance, coherence, effectiveness, efficiency, expected impact, sustainability, institutional capacity, and implementation risks.
Primary data collection included 100 community surveys, 30 key-informant interviews, 11 focus group discussions, and 11 structured field observations. Participants included adolescent girls, adult women, parents and caregivers, health workers, school representatives, government officials, civil society organisations, and project staff.
Data collection used KoboToolbox questionnaires in English and Bengali. The analysis employed a reproducible R-based workflow to calculate block-level baselines, identify priority gaps, develop a composite vulnerability ranking, and support a measurable impact matrix.
From data collection to programme decisions
The study did not treat data collection as an isolated research exercise. Findings were translated into block-specific priorities, implementation sequencing, measurable indicators, risk mitigation measures, and recommendations for cooperation with public institutions.
Selected findings
Awareness gap
Around two-thirds of respondents could not identify adolescent-friendly SRHR services, indicating that public services remain poorly understood and insufficiently visible.
Access information gap
Most respondents did not know how adolescents could access available services, showing that awareness alone will not resolve procedural and navigational barriers.
No prior service use
More than four in ten respondents reported that they, or their adolescent child, had never used an adolescent SRHR service.
Leadership gap
Three-quarters of respondents reported low confidence in approaching Panchayat representatives for support, limiting accountability and community influence.
Child marriage
Around one-third reported knowing a person in their community who had married or begun living with a partner before turning 18 during the reference period.
Climate-related disruption
Around half of households identified cyclones or storm-related hazards as a dominant threat affecting mobility, livelihoods, and continuity of health services.
What the evidence shows
Information is available, but it does not yet translate into access
Public adolescent health programmes provide an institutional foundation, but the connection between communities and services remains weak. Adolescents and caregivers often lack practical information on clinic locations, opening times, registration procedures, confidentiality, available services, and referral pathways.
This finding points to the need for navigational support rather than awareness-raising alone. Peer leaders and community facilitators can help adolescents move from knowing that a service may exist to successfully reaching and using it.
Household decision-making shapes health outcomes
Healthcare decisions were family-led in 47% of surveyed households. Among adolescent girls aged 13–17, family-led decision-making reached 94%. This restricts privacy, delays care-seeking, and can prevent adolescents from acting on information they receive.
Programmes must therefore work with girls and women while also engaging mothers, fathers, caregivers, and adolescent boys. Supporting agency without addressing household power relations may create resistance or place young participants under additional pressure.
Trust and accountability remain weak
The study identified a substantial institutional trust gap. Many respondents lacked confidence in approaching Panchayat representatives or senior health authorities. Protection concerns were more commonly associated with police and enforcement mechanisms than with preventive, health-centred support.
Stronger interfaces between girls’ federations, health providers, Panchayats, schools, and protection actors could improve service responsiveness while creating safer and more accessible routes for referral and redress.
Climate hazards intensify SRHR and protection risks
Cyclones, flooding, salinity, and water scarcity disrupt roads, transport, service availability, household income, and access to safe water. These pressures affect menstrual health, reproductive health, pregnancy-related care, personal safety, and continuity of confidential services.
Climate adaptation in the Sundarbans must therefore include social and institutional measures. Emergency referral planning, safe water access, menstrual health continuity, mobile communication, and disaster-ready community networks are all relevant to reproductive health resilience.
Geographical priorities
The feasibility study developed a composite vulnerability ranking using indicators related to knowledge, agency, service use, child marriage, early pregnancy, institutional confidence, and climate resilience.
Minakhan
Minakhan recorded the highest composite vulnerability score. The main drivers included an awareness gap of approximately 89%, an access gap of 74%, and a high prevalence of pregnancy before age 18 among relevant respondents.
Basirhat II
Basirhat II showed an awareness gap approaching 100%, alongside substantial constraints in individual agency. Initial implementation should combine intensive awareness with peer-led empowerment.
Sandeshkhali I
Sandeshkhali I showed high institutional and navigational barriers. The block requires early investment in accountability, referral pathways, and trust-building with local authorities.
Hasnabad
Hasnabad showed comparatively stronger general awareness but an access information gap approaching 90%. The priority is practical navigational support rather than broad awareness alone.
Hingalganj
Hingalganj presented a comparatively stronger baseline on several indicators. Existing community mechanisms may provide useful lessons that can inform implementation elsewhere.
A differentiated model
The findings show that uniform delivery would reduce effectiveness. Activities should respond to the dominant barrier in each block and adapt as monitoring data change.
Why these findings matter for programmes and policy
The assessment shows that improving SRHR outcomes requires more than building facilities or distributing information. Programmes must address the relationships between knowledge, household power, institutional trust, protection, service quality, and climate disruption.
The proposed peer-led federation model responds to this challenge by combining individual capacity development with collective organisation and engagement with public institutions. Girls’ collectives can provide safe spaces for learning, referral, leadership development, and participation in local decision-making.
The model also supports public systems rather than replacing them. The project seeks to improve the visibility and responsiveness of existing programmes, including RKSK and ANWESHA services, while strengthening cooperation among health workers, schools, Panchayats, civil society organisations, and protection actors.
The central lesson
Climate adaptation becomes more effective when health, gender equality, protection, local governance, and community participation are addressed together rather than through separate sectoral interventions.
Key recommendations
-
Sequence implementation according to block-level barriers.
Concentrate early awareness and demand-creation activities in Minakhan and Basirhat II. Prioritise institutional trust and referral systems in Sandeshkhali I. Focus on step-by-step service navigation in Hasnabad. -
Make navigational support a core project function.
Train peer leaders to explain service locations, clinic schedules, registration steps, confidentiality arrangements, referral options, and required documentation. Monitor whether supported adolescents complete referrals. -
Institutionalise youth-led accountability.
Establish recurring block-level forums connecting girls’ federations with health staff, Panchayats, schools, and protection actors. Each forum should track practical commitments such as clinic hours, privacy arrangements, outreach schedules, and referral procedures. -
Integrate SRHR into disaster risk reduction.
Develop contingency referral plans for floods and cyclones. Include menstrual health, safe water, confidential communication, essential commodities, pregnancy-related care, and protection referrals in local continuity planning. -
Engage caregivers, boys, and men.
Combine girls’ empowerment with structured engagement of mothers, fathers, male caregivers, and adolescent boys. This can reduce household resistance and strengthen shared responsibility for reproductive health and protection. -
Strengthen service quality and commodity reliability.
Work with public health authorities and appropriate local providers to improve confidentiality, adolescent-friendly communication, referral follow-up, menstrual health supplies, and the availability of essential reproductive health commodities. -
Use evidence for quarterly adaptive management.
Track block-level changes in awareness, access information, agency, service utilisation, institutional confidence, protection risks, and climate resilience. Adjust outreach intensity and resource allocation when monitoring identifies slow progress or emerging barriers.
Towards climate-resilient and rights-based health systems
Feasibility studies are often treated mainly as project preparation exercises. They can also generate evidence that improves public policy, strengthens programme design, and helps development actors allocate resources more effectively.
The Sundarbans study demonstrates how quantitative analysis, qualitative research, field observation, and local participation can identify practical pathways for strengthening reproductive health systems in climate-vulnerable regions.
Better programmes emerge when evidence is combined with the knowledge, agency, and participation of the people they are intended to support. This approach can improve services while strengthening trust, accountability, dignity, and the capacity of communities to navigate uncertainty.
About the feasibility study
Evidence for better development and humanitarian action
movimentar GmbH supports development and humanitarian organisations with feasibility studies, needs assessments, evaluations, digital data systems, reproducible analysis, and evidence-informed programme design.
Discuss a research, evaluation, or feasibility study












